THINK IT Services

When Oracle announced its intention to acquire Sun Microsystems in April 2009, CEO Larry Ellison proclaimed the acquisition, “transforms the IT industry, combining best-in-class enterprise software and mission-critical computing systems.”

Although he was not ready to use the term at the time, it didn’t take long for Oracle to refer to its combined capabilities as a Cloud Computing solution set, which it recently put on full display at its annual OpenWorld conference.

The event was also a coming out party for its new President, Mark Hurd, the high flying former HP CEO who departed in disgrace only a month earlier. Hurd’s appointment wasn’t hard to understand given his hardware experience at HP and NCR, and now gives Oracle’s move into the system business even more significance.

HP has retaliated by announcing the appointment of Leo Apotheker as its new CEO, along with Ray Lane as its non-executive chairman of the board. Apotheker comes to HP with extensive experience in the software industry, suggesting that the company is ready to counter Oracle’s move by escalating its own efforts in the enterprise software business.

But, Apotheker comes to HP with far less success as a software executive than Hurd achieved in his comparable time in the hardware business. Apotheker resigned as CEO of SAP AG in February after the company had fallen into a deep malaise of slow sales coupled with low customer satisfaction and employee morale.

Despite his dismal record, HP has swapped a successful hardware executive for an unsuccessful software executive.

Like nearly every other industry watcher, my friends at Triple-Tree and I didn’t see this coming when we generated our own list of potential candidates, although we were half-right in suggesting Ray Lane would be a good candidate for the top job at HP, but we didn’t necessarily mean the board chairmanship role.

Apotheker’s appointment is not only aimed at attacking Oracle’s rising threat on the systems side, but is also intended to fend off IBM’s continued push into the software business as well. Big Blue has been on a software buying spree and has done more than HP to position itself in the cloud. CA Technologies has also been acquiring an assortment of young software companies squarely focused on the cloud computing phenomenon. HP also has to reexamine its relationships with Cisco Systems and Microsoft because of their moves into the server and services businesses as well.

HP has also been engaged in an escalating battle with Dell, most recently in its fight-to-the-finish bidding war for 3PAR while it was CEO-less. In addition to competing in the server market, both companies have also deepened their services capabilities by acquiring EDS and Perot Systems respectively. I’ve questioned these moves because they are focused on the old world of IT outsourcing rather than the new world of cloud computing.

But, Apotheker’s appointment also raises serious questions about why senior executives within HP continue to be passed over for the CEO job as outsiders seem to come and go. My guess is that some of these executives will be jumping ship shortly, leaving Apotheker with the additional challenge/opportunity of building a new leadership team.

So, can Apotheker transform HP into a software-driven company? More specifically, can he transform HP’s current software business into a competitive player in the Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) market? And, can he combine HP’s software, hardware and service capabilities to create a viable cloud computing portfolio which can compete on an even broader battlefield?

If the past is any indication, the odds are against him. However, anyone who is familiar with the controversy which surrounded Bill Belichick’s hiring as the New England Patriots’ head coach in 2000 knows that he arrived with plenty of skeptics because he had failed dismally in his only other head coaching experience. Yet, he proved the skeptics wrong by leading the Patriots to three Super Bowl titles in his first five years and has continued to be a contender for the better part of the past five years as well.

Maybe Apotheker can pull off a similar surprise at HP. But, he’ll be facing far greater challenges and failure could have far greater consequences.

Some are already suggesting that one of Apotheker’s first moves should be to acquire SAP, which boasts an attractive installed base of customers who currently rely heavily on IBM systems to power SAP’s enterprise applications. Acquiring SAP would enable HP to square off against Oracle and dislodge IBM from many of these accounts. But, it could also burden HP with an aging set of on-premise applications and the same set of disgruntled customers who were happy to see Apotheker leave SAP before. (I’d be more comfortable seeing HP acquire Symantec, which would fill its security and storage management void, and would fit better into HP’s product portfolio, channel strategy and corporate culture.)

Companies often make bold moves to serve as a catalyst for change. This is certainly the intent of Apotheker’s hiring. However, HP’s board better be sure they found the right guy before they compound their past mistakes by trying to become an enterprise application vendor as well. It wasn’t too long ago that Carly Fiorina was in the midst of a series of highly publicized internal battles trying to prove the logic of her proposed acquisitons of Compaq and PwC.

The Compaq acquisition, in addition to EDS, has made HP the biggest company in the tech sector. But, they haven’t made it a leader in the rapidly evolving Cloud Computing market which is transforming the tech industry.

Apotheker refused to comment about Oracle’s strategies in response to a question during his introductory press conference, but acknowledged that the technology industry is in the midst of a very disruptive transition period as demand for cloud computing services explodes. His ultimate challenge will be transforming HP into a company which can capitalize on this extraordinary opportunity.

Mark Hurd’s sudden resignation as HP’s CEO has opened a floodgate of speculation regarding who the company will select to succeed him.

Because his departure wasn’t anticipated, there are no clear-cut internal candidates. And, because Hurd himself was a surprise selection for the post in 2006, it is possible that another little-known industry executive may be tapped again for the position this time around.

So, this creates a wonderful opportunity for anyone with a passing interest in HP’s future, and the future of the technology industry as a whole, to throw a few names in the hat.

The HP CEO position is particularly intriguing in part because it has grown to become the largest IT vendor in the industry through a series of acquisitions of Compaq, EDS and others. More importantly, HP like the rest of the IT industry is at a pivotal crossroads brought on by the disruptive forces surrounding cloud computing, globalization, the consumerization of IT, mobility and the economy.

As a consequence, HP and every other established technology (and software) company has to re-think their corporate strategies, redesign their products and services, and restructure their go-to-market tactics.

For HP, this means realigning its hardware, software and service capabilities to more effectively leverage the ‘cloud’ so it can more effectively responding to customers’ rapidly changing requirements and expectations, and compete in an increasingly competitive marketplace.

I was first prompted to think about potential HP CEO candidates immediately after Hurd’s resignation when I was asked by a top-flight headhunter for my quick suggestions and came up with the following names off the top of my head:

• Joe Tucci, EMC’s CEO who has transformed the company from a hardware-centric to a software-driven business model and pulled off a similar feat at Wang Computer where he moved the company from hardware to services. EMC and HP’s corporate capabilities and challenges have many similarities.
• John Chambers, Cisco Systems’ CEO who has successfully transformed the company from a corporate network infrastructure vendor into a multidimensional technology supplier to everyone from major service providers to small office/home office (SOHO) workers. Under Chambers’ leadership, Cisco has withstood every economic and competitive challenge, and is now moving into the data center where HP has made much of its living.
• Marc Benioff, Salesforce.com’s CEO who has transformed the software industry by leading the Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) charge and evangelizing about the added business benefits of moving to a broader array of cloud computing alternatives. If Salesforce.com isn’t going to be acquired by Oracle and Benioff made CEO under Larry Ellison, he would be a great candidate to push HP’s legacy software business into the new world of SaaS and its hardware business into the cloud.
• Steve Mills, IBM’s Software Czar, who has used an aggressive acquisition strategy to recast the company into a powerful middleware vendor within a similar set of hardware, software and service businesses which HP possesses. As a result of his success with the software division, Mills was recently given responsibility for managing IBM’s IBM hardware, storage, and operating systems businesses. But, Mills is also facing a mandatory retirement barrier to further advancement and could put his experience to good use at HP.

My friends, Chris Hoffmann and Scott Donahue at TripleTree, where I am a senior advisor, suggested that we put our heads together to broaden the candidate list. Here’s what we came up with:

• Michael Capellas- He has successfully stepped into even tougher situations at Compaq (now part of HP) and MCI/Worldcom, and is well respected in the tech industry and beyond.
• Bill Campbell - Current Intuit Chairman and former CEO, but more importantly he has been a key advisor at Google and Apple, and is also very well respected in the tech industry.
• Kevin Johnson- Former rising star at Microsoft now running Juniper Networks who understands HP’s products and channels.
• Anne Livermore- Runs HP’s Enterprise unit which brings together its hardware, software and services businesses. He’s been passed over many times but might be the safest best as an inside pick.
• John Thompson- Former CEO, and current Chairman of Symantec, recognized the importance of moving to SaaS but couldn’t overcome channel resistance.
• Meg Whitman - If the Governor thing fizzles…she’s a proven, capable leader who will be looking to prove herself again.
• Ray Lane- Ran Oracle as President, then became an early proponent of the virtues of SaaS as a top-tier VC.
• Charles Philips- Has been driving Oracle’s acquisition strategy and runnng a major portion of its operations. He’s just beginning to learn about the hardware business as a result of the Sun acquisition, but he’s a quick study and forward-minded.
• Jon Rubinstein - Ex-Palm, Ex-Apple…might be too much of an engineer but interesting match for HP. Understand mobility which is where the world is heading, and can help HP fully exploit its Palm acquisition.
• Ed Whitacre- Just announced his resignation from GM where he quicklygot the behemoth back on track with no prior industry experience. Before that, he also pulled together SBC and AT&T, and could bring HP’s far-reaching assets together. He’s in his early 60’s, so it might be a stretch to see him as a long-term CEO at HP. However, he could bring stability until HP cultivates a new leader for the longhaul.   
• Diane Greene- Former CEO of VMware revolutionized IT with virtualization, a key component in HP’s future. Might be too techie, but certainly understands the opportunities and challenges.
• Shantanu Narayen - Well respected, but not well known CEO of Adobe which is a key player in the web development world which is driving cloud services.
• Vivek Paul- CEO of Wipro, known as a visionary in outsourcing, now in private equity, with the global experience which will be essential going forward.

If these industry stalwarts seem too mundane, here are a few frivolous ideas to think about for fun:

• Brett Favre – nominated by my Minneapolis-based friends at TripleTree who worship the indecisive quarterback as a brilliant turnaround artist.
• Joe Montana – my football oriented alternative because of better winning record and Bay Area roots.
• Simon Cowell – he is a tough-minded task-master with time on his hands since he left American Idol.
• Oprah Winfrey – knows how to build businesses and a worldwide following, and might be willing to put aside her upcoming year of long goodbyes as she departs her syndicated talk show.
• Tony Blair- the consummate negotiator who would be a perfect candidate to address the myriad of channel issues which will arise if HP adopts an aggressive SaaS/cloud computing strategy.

As you can see, Mark Hurd’s resignation has given us a great way to while away the dog-days of August with various ideas. I hope this gives you plenty of food for thought for the weekend and welcome your suggestions as well.