July 13, 2010
Yes – The SaaS ‘Experiment’ Is Over
For the past two weeks, I’ve been debating whether to respond to a commentary in InfoWorld by Neil McAllister which asked, “Is the SaaS Experiment Finally Over?”
But, I couldn’t hold back any longer when one of the many online publications where I’m a contributor, eBizQ, posed the question in a more provocative fashion, “Is SaaS Dead?”
I couldn’t bring myself to respond to McAllister’s column when it was first published because his argument was so ludicrous. He alluded to a variety of past SaaS and cloud vendor service outages to raise concerns about the overall viability of these rapidly expanding markets. And he used a series of Gartnerisms to warn against developer migration to the SaaS model.
Yet, McAllister ignores the pervasive failures of traditional on-premise software which has inspired organizations of all sizes to explore and increasingly adopt SaaS alternatives to better meet their corporate needs.
The truth is that Gartner has been wrong about SaaS since the beginning. Even today, it has failed to fully recognize the current rate of SaaS adoption because they only talk to their traditional IT clients who are still trying to resist today’s trends because they see them as a threat to their jobs.
For instance, I reported earlier this year about Pacific Crest’s CIO survey which found that they expect to spend approximately 30% of their software budgets on SaaS in 2010, while Gartner is still predicting that organizations will only spend 25% of their budgets on SaaS by 2012.
Gartner also refuses to recognize the growing array of customer success stories which clearly illustrate the tangible and measurable business benefits being generated by SaaS and the broader cloud computing services.
Meanwhile, THINKstrategies has been recognizing SaaS and cloud computing providers nearly every week for the past year and a half which are delivering these business benefits worldwide through our Best of SaaS Showplace (BoSS) and Cloud Computing Business Value Award programs.
Rather than acknowledge the benefits of SaaS, and other cloud computing services, Gartner prefers to publish endless warnings which simply propose commonsense vendor selection and management principles.
The fact is that the SaaS ‘experiment’ is definitely over. It is now a mainstream movement.
Just take a look at the growth of Salesforce.com and SuccessFactors. Or, check out how NetSuite and Workday are encroaching on SAP. Listen to CIOs who are frustrated with being in the server business and want to shift into the services business.
And, pay attention to the major moves which the ‘legacy’ hardware and software players–led by IBM, HP, Microsoft, Oracle and SAP–are taking to transform and even cannibalize their traditional business to respond to rapidly escalating customer demands for change.
Yes, the SaaS experiment is over. It is now for real.


Great article – I couldn’t agree more.
For EasyVista, the rate of SaaS adoption is increasing dramatically when compared to On-Premise. This includes new EasyVista customers and current customers actively transitioning from EasyVista On-Premise to SaaS.
Over 90% of our prospects want to discuss both SaaS and On-Premise. A greater percentage of those are choosing SaaS. The trend is obvious.
The problem with traditional legacy vendors (BMC, HP, CA) is they cannot provide true SaaS and are muddying the water. As the very important “Service” factor of SaaS continues to increase it’s value to IT and the business through enhanced Services, vendors that don’t address adapting customer requirements will continue to lose market share.
EasyVista customers believe in the value of SaaS and so do we.
Evan Carlson — July 13, 2010 @ 6:25 pm
Love the write-up Jeff and looking forward to highlighting your saas-showplace.com on our new site which as Evan stated perfectly is all about moving to the cloud to save money and time to market.
We have members who use many of your BoSS winners and now want to integrate those to their other systems both on-premise and in the cloud so we are leading the way in showing them how this can be done and where to begin the process.
Always a great morning when I peruse your blog out here in San Francisco before the day really gets going.
~Cheers,
Clint
@cazoomi
Clint Wilson — July 14, 2010 @ 9:12 am
Yes, Jeff, there are still naysayers. SaaS has crossed the chasm.
Among our competitors in ERP for manufacturing, there is growing realization of how important SaaS is becoming. Now, the laggards are scrambling to come up with offerings that look like SaaS. They shroud their legacy products in “cloud” nomenclature so as not to be eliminated from sales cycles.
Thanks for your continued voice on this topic.
Mark Symonds — July 15, 2010 @ 11:21 am